hmmm...you put a lot of time into open ended shooters, but it seems like you really prefer games that simply give you a lot of value for your money while still remaining fun. IDK. Maybe I'm off base here.
It feels like Garry's Mod might be worth your keys, or possibly Dark Souls or Fable Anniversary. None are on your wishlist however, so I'm really just throwing suggestions your way.
If one of those sounds good, let me know. If not, no worries.
I would throw in a pair of game keys of your choice from my 4 ref tier as well to make it a bit more equitable: https://www.steamtrades.com/trade/4m8lW/h-lots-of-games-party-hard-spelunky-dark-souls-etcwindborne-updated-w-keys-ref
castle crashers/terraria/insurgecy (latam)/ dont starve togheter (latam) / garrys mod / euro truck simulator 2 / speed runners /deponia/mount your friends ?
anything here ?
Kingdom Rush
Thomas Was Alone
Broken Age
The Magic Circle
South Park: The Stick of Truth
Hand Of Fate
Braid
Lovely Planet
Unmechanical
Spec Ops: The Line
Brothers - A Tale of Two Sons
Skulls of the Shogun
Bulb Boy
Another World – 20th Anniversary Edition
Axis Football 2015
Mafia II: Digital Deluxe Edition
Victor Vran
Valkyria Chronicles
METAL GEAR SOLID V: GROUND ZEROES
Shantae and the Pirate's Curse
The Legend of Korra (Steam-Gift)
DmC: Devil May Cry
Renowned Explorers: International Society
This War of Mine
Crawl
-
-