"and am willing to trade it for Scribblenauts Unlimited (ideally combined with another game so that the deal is fair)"
Sale price on Dishonored is $30 ($25 from GoG), sale price on Scribblenauts is $30. And Scribblenauts is newer and rarer. Sorry, but you'll be lucky if you can find someone to do this even 1:1
Dishonored is a $60 quality game (which is not offered on Good Old Games, by the way) and Scribblenauts Unlimited is a $30 casual game. Both games were released approximately at the same time: 20 November for Scribblenauts, 9 October for Dishonored. Furthermore, Scribblenauts will probably be available on the winter sale for $15 in about a week. My deal is excellent (and the current highest on SteamTrades). You are simply confused (or trying to over-inflate the prices for your own benefit).
I can get you Scribblenauts, but need a confirmation from your end first. Add me on steam to discuss
Alright, already added you.
Update: Someone already traded me Scribblenauts Unlimited about 1 hour after you logged off. However, I still have another copy of Dishonored (but it is a key from a physical box), in case you are interested. (Check out my trading thread if you are interested.) Other than that, you are still welcome in my giveaway group.
You read correctly. I have a tradable copy of Dishonored and am willing to trade it for Scribblenauts Unlimited (ideally combined with another game so that the deal is fair). If you don't want or already have Dishonored, I am open to making a trade for another quality game of your choosing. Just let me know what you want as there is a chance I may already have it (or am able to get it, if I don't have it).
Please make reasonable offers: after all, Scribblenauts Unlimited is only a $30 game. The only reason it seems "worth" so much is because no one seems to have it due to a lack of interest (less than 300 people pre-ordered it despite the Team Fortress 2 items) and because it is not available worldwide. Soon, in the coming months, it will be available in more regions and will be worth a lot less than it is now.
That said, this offer is only open for about a week. If I haven't found a copy of Scribblenauts Unlimited in that time, I will trade my copy of Dishonored for something else.